An Inconvenient Truth

There is something I wanted to write about for months now, and I decided to finally take it on, but I will try my best to make this a series of short entries instead of one endlessly long entry (or, worse, a series of endlessly long entries).

There is a blog entry on the internet which most of you probably do not know about, and I believe it is one of the most important pieces ever written about Magic. I give you the link further down, but I ask you to click it only after you read a few sentences I want to say about it first.

The writer of this article – going by CML – is full up to the brim with negativity, and it is easy to see that this is rooted deeply in his own private issues. There are a lot of obvious points to bring up against his rant: He is projecting his own negativity onto his hobby; he didn’t prepare for his PT experience, so he deservedly did badly and then felt bad about it; he is antagonistic towards other people and the PT community in general, so it is no wonder that he isn’t feeling comfortable in that community or making friends there. All in all, his article is overripe for rebuttals along the lines of „you see what you want to see“, or „you get out of it what you put into it.“

And yet, viewing his text only through this lens would be a big mistake. For one thing, he states some painfully obvious facts which other authors do not seem to bother with, or do not dare to write about. Also, just like negativity may blind you for good things you encounter, so can positivity blind you to bad stuff – but this writer kept his eyes wide open for the bad stuff and saw many things a lot more clearly than most. Lastly, that such a miserable and self-loathing individual felt a pull to compete in the Magic Pro Tour doesn’t seem to be a coincidence: My impression is that he is prototypical for a great many players with similar feelings and disposition, but he is the rare exception to write honestly about those. It is very interesting food for thought that the Magic Pro Tour seems to be tailor-made for such people…

I will go over that author’s claims in detail in future entries – there is a LOT to say! – but for the time being, I’ll leave you with the link to the original text:


The Magic: the Gathering Pro Tour Sucks

markiert , , , , ,

3 Gedanken zu „An Inconvenient Truth

  1. Freakle sagt:

    That blog post you link was a horrible read from a small minded person. Really curious to see why you want to talk about this besides stuff like price payouts from mtg compared to esports.

    Looking forward to your thoughts, that linked post however is not worth anybodys time.

    • Tigris sagt:

      Why? Because you didn’t liked his oppinion?
      For me it was quite interesting to read. (I knew it before this blog post though).

      • Freakle sagt:

        no, because most of his complains are not about the event, nor the place they stayed in (and really, if you get angry about not everybody in belgium speaking english, as a person that obviously does not speak any language besides it), nearly all of his complains are about himself, reflected on whatever he just saw.

        i like his writing style (although Pischner already had to comment on in another blog post on his high horse, but whatever), but his complains have a bare minimum to do with the event he traveled to.

Kommentare sind geschlossen.